20,000 USDC
View results
Submission Details
Severity: gas
Valid

QA3-InterfaceAndComments-CarlosAlegreUr

Summary 📌

I'm suggesting some refactoring and additional comments to enhance code readability and comprehension.

Vulnerability Details 🔍

Refactor: Interface Creation 🛠️:

Create ILender.sol. Have Lender.sol inherit from it. This encapsulates events and provides clarity about the functions in the Lender.sol contract and their purposes.

pragma solidity ^0.8.19;
// Some imports...
interface ILender {
// The events...
event Borrowed();
event Repaid();
// Functions with their documentation, preferably using NatSpec
}

Comments' Improvements 🖊️

  • Beedle.sol : This contract lacks comments. Please provide context and documentation.

  • Fees.sol : Include a summary comment at the beginning detailing the contract's purpose and functions.

  • Existing Comments Enhancement Proposal:
    For instance, in setPool(), include:

    @notice Ensure the lender approves the required token transfers before invoking.

    This last proposal should be added in any function that involves token transferFrom. Those functions are:

    • addToPool

    • borrow()

    • repay()

    • refinance()

It is recommended that these comment suggestions are applied to the rest of the codebase and in future modifications to it.

Impact 📈

These modifications are predicted to reduce the time future developers spend understanding the code components, resulting in a faster development environment.

Tools Used 🛠️

  • Manual audit.

Recommendations 🎯

Spending time properly commenting the code when a project is complex is essential. It saves lots of time for developers trying to understand and work or improve the codebase.

🚧 Note ⚠️: I've previously sent a report suggesting deeper structural changes to Lender.sol. However, if implementing those changes proves too time-consuming or complex for the dev team, this current suggestion offers a less intensive alternative that still enhances code quality.

Support

FAQs

Can't find an answer? Chat with us on Discord, Twitter or Linkedin.