Core Contracts

Regnum Aurum Acquisition Corp
HardhatReal World AssetsNFT
77,280 USDC
View results
Submission Details
Severity: low
Invalid

The RAACMinter contract currently lacks detailed documentation for complex calculations, making maintenance and understanding of the system challenging.

Based on the findings from the RAACMinter contract audit, here is a comprehensive documentation improvement plan that i draft for them:

Documentation Enhancement Report

Current Status

The RAACMinter contract currently lacks detailed documentation for complex calculations, making maintenance and understanding of the system challenging. This documentation gap affects:

  • Complex mathematical operations in emission rate calculations

  • System state transitions

  • Token distribution logic

  • Role-based access control implementation

Documentation Structure

To address these gaps, we recommend implementing the following documentation structure:

  1. Contract Overview```solidity
    /**

  • @title RAACMinter

  • @author RegnumAurumAcquisitionCorp

  • @notice Manages the minting and distribution of RAAC tokens based on a dynamic emissions schedule.

  • @dev This contract implements a minting strategy that adjusts based on system utilization.

  • The emission rate is calculated using a dynamic formula that considers:
  • - Current utilization rate
  • - Adjustment factor
  • - Benchmark rate
  • - Minimum and maximum emission rates

*/

2. **Complex Calculation Documentation**
```solidity
/**
* @dev Calculates the new emission rate based on system utilization and benchmark rate.
* The calculation follows these steps:
* 1. Get current utilization rate from lending pool and stability pool
* 2. Calculate adjustment amount based on current rate and adjustment factor
* 3. Apply adjustment based on utilization target:
* - If utilization > target: Increase rate up to benchmark
* - If utilization < target: Decrease rate down to benchmark
* 4. Ensure result stays within min/max bounds
*
* @return uint256 The new emission rate in RAAC per block
*/
function calculateNewEmissionRate() internal view returns (uint256) {
// ... implementation
}
  1. State Management Documentation
    ```solidity
    /**

  • @notice State variables for emission control

  • @dev These variables work together to manage the token emission schedule:

    • emissionRate: Current rate of token emission per block

    • lastUpdateBlock: Tracks when the last emission update occurred

    • lastEmissionUpdateTimestamp: Timestamp of last rate update

    • excessTokens: Accumulated tokens for future distribution
      */
      uint256 public emissionRate;
      uint256 public lastUpdateBlock;
      uint256 public lastEmissionUpdateTimestamp;
      uint256 public excessTokens;

4. **Role-Based Access Control**
```solidity
/**
* @notice Role definitions for access control
* @dev The contract implements three key roles:
* PAUSER_ROLE: Controls contract pausing functionality
* UPDATER_ROLE: Manages parameter updates and configurations
* EMERGENCY_SHUTDOWN_ROLE: Handles emergency shutdown procedures
*/
bytes32 public constant PAUSER_ROLE = keccak256("PAUSER_ROLE");
bytes32 public constant UPDATER_ROLE = keccak256("UPDATER_ROLE");
bytes32 public constant EMERGENCY_SHUTDOWN_ROLE = keccak256("EMERGENCY_SHUTDOWN_ROLE");

Implementation Guidelines

  1. Comment Structure - Use NatSpec format for all documentation

  • Include @notice for user-facing information

  • Use @dev for technical implementation details

  • Document all parameters and return values

  • Explain complex calculations step-by-step

  1. Documentation Placement - Place comments immediately above functions and variables

  • Group related documentation together

  • Include examples where complex logic is involved

  • Reference related functions and variables

  1. Maintenance Considerations - Update documentation with each code change

  • Review documentation during code reviews

  • Use consistent terminology throughout

  • Include version information in documentation

Implementation Timeline

  1. Immediate Actions - Add NatSpec comments to all public functions

  • Document state variables and their relationships

  • Create overview documentation for complex calculations

  1. Short-Term Goals - Complete documentation for all functions

  • Add role-based access control documentation

  • Document system state transitions

Verification Process

To ensure documentation quality:

  1. Technical Review - Verify accuracy of technical descriptions

  • Check consistency with implementation

  • Validate mathematical formulas

  1. Maintenance Review - Ensure documentation is clear to new developers

  • Verify completeness of state transitions

  • Check accessibility of information

This documentation enhancement plan will significantly improve the maintainability and understanding of the RAACMinter contract while following industry best practices for smart contract documentation.

Updates

Lead Judging Commences

inallhonesty Lead Judge 4 months ago
Submission Judgement Published
Invalidated
Reason: Non-acceptable severity

Support

FAQs

Can't find an answer? Chat with us on Discord, Twitter or Linkedin.